Welcome to Brainstorm, our new editorial roundtable feature. Bringing together multiple viewpoints on a single issue, Brainstorm provides you with a variety of opinions from all the points of the compass. In addition, we give you the chance to add your own thoughts to the mix along with those of your fellow readers.

The October issue features commentary from experts in the field of portable power who answered the following questions asked by the ECN editorial staff: What do you consider to be the most important factors that will further the development of power management in portable systems? What do you think are some of the customer misconceptions about power management that must overcome to move the industry forward?

Mel Berman, Lambda Americas, Inc.LambdaLambda_brain_web.jpg
"...It is obvious that battery technology advances will play a major role in the development of portable devices and systems. As the newer battery technologies come to fruition, the power management controls and ICs will need to adapt in order to maximize the battery’s power-on time, reduce the recharge time, and extend its useful life. ...Within the portable devices, the DC/DC and POL (point-of-load) converters' improved efficiencies will play a major role in reducing any wasted energy drains from the battery. "The OEM may not be aware of the power management techniques that can best facilitate these results. Many times we hear about customer dissatisfaction with short-battery operate times, long recharge-times, and even catastrophic failures of the products, which in some cases may have been avoided by the use of improved power management and monitoring techniques." Click here for complete comment 

brain_dbagg_web.jpgDave Baggaley, Inspired Energy
"Chip manufacturers aim their marketing at engineers, but the real end product is a portable electronic device that works seamlessly with its smart-battery pack. What is needed is a program which reaches the marketing department in the device manufacturer. “If you implement “Q” power management, your device will be able to do “X”, “Y” & “Z”, increasing the user benefits for your device.” Click here for complete comment 

 Brian_web_linear.jpgTony Armstrong, Linear Technologies 
"The demands on the battery to deliver the necessary power have grown drastically. However, the batteries' form factor has remained relatively small, and only modest gains in power density have been realized. As a result, battery run-time has become a significant selling feature in most portable handheld devices creating a need for very compact and high efficiency multiple output synchronous buck converters." "The fact is that most battery-powered handheld products have used an application specific integrated circuit (ASIC, or PMIC) to deal with the requirements of battery charging, power-path control, providing multiple supply voltages, as well as protection features such as true output disconnect and accurate USB current limiting. ...Customers have adopted such an approach so they can obtain a single device that meets all of their power management needs. "However, there are also drawbacks to this approach. First of all, ASICs are manufactured on a specific wafer fabrication process, making it difficult to maximize their performance for each of these functions. Secondly, and becoming more important in these times of short, dynamic design cycles, is the long lead-time associated with the definition and development of an ASIC. It is common for a power management ASIC to take two years or more to produce from conception to delivery. During this time, the design needs for a particular product could have changed three or more times." Click here for complete comment 

Doug Bailey, Power Integrationsseptember_brain_power_int.jpg
"Several converging market factors are acting as agents of change in power supplies for portable systems. First, Apple’s leadership in industrial design for portable computing and communication products has educated consumers to expect sleek, thin and sexy design — an expectation that extends to the peripherals, including AC adapters. Consumers are also more environmentally conscious, better informed and able to exercise eco-choices when making purchasing decisions. Coupled with the ever tightening mesh of efficiency regulations worldwide, these consumer preferences for small size and low weight are pushing the market towards thin, energy efficient power adapters. "The favorite historical debate in the power community is whether the feedback in a PWM should be voltage mode or current mode. The new faiths competing for attention contrast the effectiveness of analog and digital power control loops. ...The recent clamor and promotion of digital power management in some circles has helped to highlight the benefits of a number of very useful techniques. However, dogmatic adherence to digital as the way forward for all power products can close minds to some very elegant and effective analog alternatives." Click here for complete comment 

 Tim Phillips, International Rectifier Corp.
IR_headshot_web.jpg"Typically, power management was a secondary consideration when architecting a system and the ‘management’ segment of power management became mainly a game of thermal management. However, energy costs and environmental concerns are driving performance metrics to move from ‘instructions per second’ to ‘instructions per Watt’, and efficiency has become as important — or more important — than absolute performance. "Extending battery life continues to be one of the most important goals in portable power systems. Battery technology has not kept pace with the new functions (and power demand) in shrinking form factors. The role of the power management system is to intelligently and efficiently parcel battery charge to the most valuable function(s) at a given moment." Click here for complete comment.
 Dr. Paul Magill, Nextreme, Inc. 
PMagill_WEB.jpg"The heat rejection system is the critical link in the thermal path. For portable systems, properly engineering this part of the system is essential to realizing the potential for this technology. ...One other area that needs a concomitant focus is the conversion efficiency of the thermally derived energy to electrical energy. Finally, combining portable power with power storage (batteries) may also further the development of power management in portable systems. "Customers tend to focus their buying decisions on what gives them the biggest bang or what in other words what offers the most power. The customer instead should focus on which solution provides the best match to their needs....Thermoelectrics offer a long-term power solution. Batteries offer a short-term power solution. Battery disposal is an issue that is creeping up and will require increasing attention." Click here for complete comment.

(way below)

Related Articles

Power in My Pocket
Exploding Functionality Collides With Size/Power Constraints
Super Capacitors Present New Challenges for System Designers
Chip-Scale MOSFETs for Managing Li-Ion Batteries
Save Space and Improve System Performance for Handheld Devices with PMIC
Improved EMC/EMI Performance Using Active Analog Power Filters
Optimized Displays Address the Power Woes of Mobile Devices 

Related ECN Design Network Sessions

Intro to Digital Power 
Battery Selection for Portable Power Applications
Common Mistakes In Battery Pack Development (and how to avoid them) 
An Introduction to Ultracapacitors
Power Supply 101: Introduction to Power Supply Concepts
Battery Selection for Portable Power Applications
Preventing Dangerous Battery System Failures